Discussion about this post

User's avatar
H.P. De Veer's avatar

I think the saddest part is that most of the people who "pull the levers" already know this. There is a gaping void in our culture, a constant tearing down of structures of meaning with nothing in sight to replace them. The task of deconstruction only feels as meaningful for as long as the orgiastic destruction is happening. When it's done and you're left with nothing but rubble, that empty feeling sets in again. You go from structure to structure, seeking and destroying over and over again until there is nothing but barren earth, nothing to tear down but yourself. And because it's all you know to do, you tear down that last thing as well.

They pull all the levers there are, but there is no lever for this. You can will people to do as you say, talk as you say, support what you say, but you cannot *make* people feel something. Even false consciousness only goes so far. The only way for a person to feel something is if they feel it. When you create a culture that does nothing but numb, people will come up with some crazy ways to "feel" to fight that.

We have to start creating things. We have to start cobbling together bits of space debris to build new things, new spaces, new frontiers that give hope and inspire creativity and imagination. We have almost completely run out of runway, our movies and tv shows have lost the ability to imagine anything exciting and new and "possible." Instead we are stuck on a treadmill of nostalgia, wishing things were "like they used to be." Complaining about how things are.

Substack, in a way, can be a meaningful frontier for us. It can be a place where we build possibility as often as we fight the hegemonic cultural hypnosis. We have to build, we have to think of what's next, we have to create a culture of the 2020s. Let's stop waiting for permission, stop begging to be "let into the room" of MSM and Hollywood. Let's make our own place.

Very powerful, grim, and yet also motivating article. Thank you @defaultfriend

Expand full comment
Chris Roach's avatar

It's worth noting that there is a strong element of the suicidal among mass shooters, which is also a growing phenomenon and also a product of alienation and nihilism. As the modern world came into focus, Durkheim wrote about this in what may be called the first work of sociology, finding suicide more pronounced among the more industrially advanced, individualist, and protestant cultures within Europe.

Expand full comment
74 more comments...

No posts