75 Comments
User's avatar
H.P. De Veer's avatar

I think the saddest part is that most of the people who "pull the levers" already know this. There is a gaping void in our culture, a constant tearing down of structures of meaning with nothing in sight to replace them. The task of deconstruction only feels as meaningful for as long as the orgiastic destruction is happening. When it's done and you're left with nothing but rubble, that empty feeling sets in again. You go from structure to structure, seeking and destroying over and over again until there is nothing but barren earth, nothing to tear down but yourself. And because it's all you know to do, you tear down that last thing as well.

They pull all the levers there are, but there is no lever for this. You can will people to do as you say, talk as you say, support what you say, but you cannot *make* people feel something. Even false consciousness only goes so far. The only way for a person to feel something is if they feel it. When you create a culture that does nothing but numb, people will come up with some crazy ways to "feel" to fight that.

We have to start creating things. We have to start cobbling together bits of space debris to build new things, new spaces, new frontiers that give hope and inspire creativity and imagination. We have almost completely run out of runway, our movies and tv shows have lost the ability to imagine anything exciting and new and "possible." Instead we are stuck on a treadmill of nostalgia, wishing things were "like they used to be." Complaining about how things are.

Substack, in a way, can be a meaningful frontier for us. It can be a place where we build possibility as often as we fight the hegemonic cultural hypnosis. We have to build, we have to think of what's next, we have to create a culture of the 2020s. Let's stop waiting for permission, stop begging to be "let into the room" of MSM and Hollywood. Let's make our own place.

Very powerful, grim, and yet also motivating article. Thank you @defaultfriend

Chris Roach's avatar

It's worth noting that there is a strong element of the suicidal among mass shooters, which is also a growing phenomenon and also a product of alienation and nihilism. As the modern world came into focus, Durkheim wrote about this in what may be called the first work of sociology, finding suicide more pronounced among the more industrially advanced, individualist, and protestant cultures within Europe.

Pedro L. Gonzalez's avatar

You should write that essay!

William Hickey's avatar

“Those who have only empty space above them are almost inevitably lost in it, if no force restrains them.”

Emile Durkheim, “Suicide”

Ryan Petty's avatar

Correct. See the work of the US Secret Service (NTAC) and Dr. Kelly Posner.

David P. Martinez's avatar

The answer of course is Jesus Christ. He is the Way, the Truth and the Life. He loves humanity and wishes that all of us may join Him in heaven forever, but while we are here on earth we must take up our cross and follow Him. On earth we indeed will suffer, for this life is a valley of tears. However if we follow His commands and love Him with all of our heart, soul, mind and strength and love our neighbor(fellow man) as ourselves we have the great Hope of a life of eternal bliss after our life here on earth is over. This is the complete solution to the nihilism described in the well written article.

RinglessSaturn's avatar

While I agree with you of the correct solution, it’s worth understanding the actual spiritual situation that we’re in. These people (most people) have no concept of Hope or Truth or Life. If there were any submission to any Law above their own perception, Christian, Muslim, Mormon, even human-sacrificing Pagan, there would be something left after everything literal was stripped away or rendered meaningless, something would be left beyond their own existence as meat and suffering. There would have been a bottom. With God there is no bottom. I found Lewis’ ‘A Christmas Sermon for Pagans’ helpful, with the understanding that we are several orders of magnitude worse off than in the 1950s.

Robert Sparrow's avatar

That's so shallow, tepid and what we have heard our entire lives. It's not wrong per se but it's so easy for "the man with the book" to keep repeating this while the whole moral system is ways more complex and contradictory when you're in hell.

Jeff Johnson's avatar

Amen, my brother! And those of us who know this must continue to spread this very Gospel to the worlds you and I touch each day.

Chili Peeper's avatar

It's more than just nihilism. I think life is meaningless, but I never wanted to shoot people. What you are all missing from the equation is a necessary ingredient in nearly all, if not all, of these shootings: real love and kindness from a parent. These shooters are much more than missing meaning in life, THEY ARE ANGRY and have ZERO empathy. If they had a single parent or grandparent that showed them REAL LOVE, they wouldn't be able to do what they do. Believe it.

Midwest Molly's avatar

All of them have traumatic childhoods and chaotic parents. You can theorize all you want, but fucking up a child's first five years of life pays horrific dividends.

κρῠπτός's avatar

Yes. Nihilism. But how does one recapture meaning? In the materialist world that spits out the nihilist, we must rediscover the larger supernatural reality within which the natural is cradled. “Repent and believe because the kingdom of God is near”

Ernst Jünger: Prayer “possesses a conducive power.” Without prayer, “our freedom of will and powers of resistance diminish; the appeal of demonic powers becomes more compelling, and it’s imperatives more terrible.”

David Cannady's avatar

This isn't a problem of "individualism", we are individuals. One cannot have a relationship with "society", but only with other individuals. You can claim that Liberalism is at fault, but we haven't had actual Liberalism in America for a very long time. What we've had is the imposition of collectivism. We are each classified at an early age as a "type", nerd, jock, hoodlum, whatever, and ascribed a set of behavioral properties that are entirely dehumanizing. The person who can't be categorized and doesn't have solid family support becomes isolated and is dealt with contemptuously.

No one quotes Thomas Jefferson before committing mass murder.

The Sentient Dog Group's avatar

Jefferson gleefully categorized people. There was his idealized rural yeoman farmer types. The merchants and bankers of the cities that he didn't trust. Of course there were the plantation owners, of which he was one. And, let's not forget, slaves, which yes we can say "it's complicated". The point, though, is that since our personal one on one relationships are limited (Dunbars Number implies it maxes out at 150) we will always resort to categories in any society that is beyond a small tribe.

Engineer 2.0's avatar

I enjoyed your essay Katherine, and I think you are right to see that nihilistic philosophy underlies the despair and hopelessness that so many feel.

Harlan Dietrich's avatar

Important take. I think there is also overlap here with the proliferation of hardcore pornography that Katherine has written about. Everything seems tethered to the embrace of meaninglessness. Your body, your dignity, your life.

James McQuivey's avatar

Your point is powerful. But might I suggest some additional thoughts to consider. Because young men have always been at risk for adverse behaviors, not just in the face of the nihilism of the present moment which you describe so well. Weirdly, most societies seem to know this and can even find ways for those at-risk men to find a niche, including explicitly giving those most at-risk men the most violent outlets. An example: An analysis of suicide bombers in the Middle East a few years back found that they were most likely to be the 3rd, 4th, or 5th sons of their families. No inheritance available to them, little likelihood of a favorable marriage match, and therefore most likely to be a risk to the community (in terms of sexual violence or other locally directed misbehavior). The solution, apparently, is to raise them to glorify their families by becoming suicide bombers or other expendable agents of outward-directed violence. Similarly: Swiss villages were famous throughout the middle ages for producing an excess of healthy, strong men who, if they were also the 3rd, 4th, or 5th+ sons, would have no hope of inheriting land in the densely populated and intensively cultivated land of Switzerland. With a national policy of not expanding Swiss borders, the Swiss could not recruit these men to enforce Swiss colonial ambition in faraway lands but instead deployed these "excess" young men as mercenaries -- paid soldiers -- where they would either earn the wealth they couldn't get at home or simply never come home. Relatedly, Irish families for centuries prepared their "excess" sons to be priests, a more benign alternative, but high in purpose and status for the family (and prevented, typically, further offspring with even less inheritance potential). I've overly summarized for present purposes, but it seems clear that cultures intuitively recognize that they need to provide high-risk/high-reward options for their "excess" young men, at least when population is above a certain size. But you can only do that for a subset of your young men (and I'm obviously not endorsing even these).

Our problem comes to light when you consider that all of these cases, the society first provides a clear path for the 1st and 2nd sons in the family. Meaning the bulk of young men have a path for fulfilling their biological drives. Yes, those paths are overly determined, inflexible, and a burden to carry (at least as seen through the eyes of American pop culture), but those paths are also supported by the community, provide access to community resources, and channel the energy -- including dark energy -- of the young men involved. Today, our culture doesn't even offer 1st and 2nd sons a clear path. Marriage is for conservative fools, parenting should be put off if done at all, and continuing in the value and faith traditions of your community makes you look like Jon Lithgow in Footloose: You believe in nonsense and are thus shackling yourself to the past, unable to revel in your freedom, dancing through an abandoned barn a la Kevin Bacon.

So here we stand. Where prior societies have had to deal with the risks posed by a handful of "excess" sons, our culture has made all our sons "excess." Yes, nihilism abounds. But that nihilism may not just be a product of feeling like nothing matters, a haunting fear that I presume is a human universal, it is also the result of a deliberate campaign to stamp out the processes and patterns of culture that afford us the very things that our bodies evolved to prize: pair bonding, procreation, and providing for the next generation. Men and women alike are losing their connection to this urge. It's just that for a small percentage of these increasingly "excess" men, the only way out is to go out with an awful, terrible bang.

Charles Mitchell's avatar

Yes, we're all 5th sons these days. I agree. What lies in front of us is the knitting of a new meaning. Men need to become adventurers of connection.

smolfeeshaver's avatar

Lack of meaning or lack of tribe?

Clever Pseudonym's avatar

This is an excellent point.

I come from Queens, NY, land of immigrants, and while my friends and I (and our children) are swept along w everyone else in the meaningless void of consumerist America, we are all deeply rooted in our families, tribes and neighborhoods.

I am Italian-American, my best friends are Puerto Rican or Greek or Russian Jewish Americans, and none of us seem to have gone too far down the nihilist rabbit hole: there are just too many friends and families around, too many communal events (too many! ;)), our parents' voices and expectations are always there ringing in our ears (not to mention aunts and uncles and siblings and grandparents)—it does seem to make us a touch more level-headed and not as prone to the deeper currents of alienation.

I think Simone Weil has written the most interesting work about this in "The Need For Roots".

Charles Mitchell's avatar

It's also interesting to note how those connections even add up to better health outcomes. It's our bodies that want us to be connected, too.

BonnyW's avatar

A really thoughtful and thought-provoking essay. When our roles in our families and our communities are diminished by the view that government is the go to resource, the ultimate problem solver, we lose even more of the cohesive, ‘serving something larger than ourselves’ purpose that gives life meaning. As long as government is seen as the one responsible for addressing problems, it corrodes our opportunities for, and need, to be a part of the type of service which gives life meaning. Without opportunities to make a difference, we see no purpose. Government cannot be the only ‘other’ in our lives - it is not a replacement for the genuine relationships constructed by individuals within a community. I’m reminded a bit of the ideas within Putnam’s valuable book ‘Bowling Alone’. Thanks for the great essay, Katherine.

Neil Kellen's avatar

If there is no truth, there is no meaning. The left in the US does not believe in any truths, only power.

Mike Sweeten's avatar

That was an impressive list of causes in the forth paragraph, more than I've ever heard from a politician. You don't think those things are upstream from nihilism? Those things are both symptoms and causes. Great essay though.

Brian's avatar

nihilism and the loss of hope for the future. it's easy to be sucked down that rabbit hole.

wombatlife's avatar

"Until we see this, the ground of the problem, we will be no closer to answers, let alone solutions for these 21st-century horrors."

Nihilism isn't unique to our century. Dostoyevsky wrote about it in the 19th century and Sartre in the 20th century.

What makes our current nihilism especially lethal?

Rob Nikada's avatar

The nihilism in 19th century Russia gave rise to something very lethal.

Phillip's avatar

Simple: the material conditions of the West have removed the shock absorbers - family, community, society and the shared purposes generated by inherited forms of culture and society. The artificial substitutes on offer to replace these (mass culture, infotainment) are transparently instrumental. Impersonal institutions cannot substitute for organic and self-renewing forms of association like the family. The rising frequency of extreme forms of social isolation multiplies the number of people living in psychically unendurable conditions. The powers that be are not going to change anything. They will hoard social capital and suppress the formation of social capital within the general population because a demoralised, dispirited, mass cannot resist control from above.

Jax's avatar

Prozac, Ritalin, and the rest of the pharmacopeia pumped into western infants from birth?

Lillia Gajewski's avatar

The number of people packed in one place and the fact you can't get away.